Let’s clear something up right off the bat: there’s a difference between rooting for a team and expecting that team to win it all. I root for the Marlins because I think they’re a likable, talented bunch and I want to see them succeed. I was happy to cheer for them this season, even when it became clear that the only way they were going to the World Series is if they bought tickets from a scalper.
So just because I predict a winner doesn’t mean I’m rooting for that team. It’s like when Halladay pitched against the Marlins: I expected a Phillies victory, but I rooted for my team.
So with that in mind, my picks for the postseason:
National League


Phillies will beat the Cardinals in four games. Cards are a talented bunch riding a high, but the Phillies didn’t get to 102 wins this season by allowing opponents to extend streaks against them.
I’ll take the Brewers over the Diamondbacks, although this one is more likely to go all five games. But it almost doesn’t matter because…
The Phillies will win the NLCS, and if it takes six games for them to do it, I will be genuinely surprised.
American League:

Yankees will have a tough go of it, but I think they will beat the Tigers in five. I think they realize this is the last time we’ll see Jeter, Posada and Rivera in the postseason, and something happens to this team in October that’s hard to quantify. It ain’t numbers. It’s almost magic. You can call it what you want, but you can’t deny it.
Rangers have a lot to prove after their disappointing performance at last year’s World Series, and if they can beat the Rays’ outstanding pitching, they’ll need all five games to do it. That’s a big if.
The rematch is going to be exciting as hell, but somehow, I doubt the Yankees will fall to the Rangers two years in a row. They’re onto you, Texas. Yankees in five or six.
World Series
A rematch of the 2009 World Series: Phillies are hungry and on fire. Yankees want one more jewel on the crown that has been Derek Jeter’s career. But Yankees have been known to fall short in such circumstances. Remember 2001? Just a few weeks after 9/11, the universe was rooting for NY, and the Yankees couldn’t quite do it? Yeah, I’m thinking this is that kind of year: Rematch goes to the Phillies.
But I’m ROOTING for…
